This story is pretty upsetting on its own: 53 illegal immigrants essentially kidnapped and held against their will. Sorry, I don’t care if they were trying to enter America illegally. They are still HUMAN and shouldn’t be treated like this.
However, it’s the comments that really made me want to kill someone.
Here is just a taste:
“Make them WALK home, with our Border Patrol kicking them in their arses all the way to the border!…This crap has got to stop. These people are destroying our cities, states and country and threatening our culture and jobs and way of life, etc. What makes them so special that they don’t have to obey our laws, etc.?! They have no right to come here illegally! Mexico’s a ‘new world’ country itself that’s even been a country 100 years longer than the United States. It’s time they got their sheeet together and made something out of their miserable, corrupt country and took care of their own people.”
“GOOD FOR PHOENIX !!!!! ILLEGALS THAT BREAK OUR LAWS HAVE NO RIGHTS!!!!!!!! I agree….No FREE FLIGHTS…..Drop them in the ocean off the lowest point in mexico.
AMERICA IS FIGHTING BACK!!! NO RIGHTS<NO SPECIAL TREATMENTS FOR ILLEGALS!!!! Call AUTHORITIES EVERY TIME YOU SUSPECT AN ILLEGAL, Then, report the person hiring them!!!! The ILLEGALS are TERRIBLE WORKERS, DO A SLOPPY JOB,And COMMIT CRIMES…LOAD your weapons AMERICA !!!““Who the hell are they seeking ransom from???? They’re asking for $2,500 for each person- FROM WHOM???? Please, God, I pray to you that my government in some way doesn’t pay for this…no human rights excuses, no nothing. It’ll be interesting to see the circumstances in which these people are let go. It’ll be interesting to see if someone gets piad, and who cuts the check.”
“Are we PROSECUTING the illegal invaders? Hell no, that would destroy the story’s “human interest” angle. Why, those poor, poor illegal alien invaders were VICTIMS, weren’t they? NO, they’re NOT. They’re CRIMINALS, caught red-handed invading the United States. Brietbart needs to try sticking to the TRUTH in these stories, rather than portraying criminals as victims for the emotional (read “liberal”) appeal.”
(all emphasis mine)
There’s tons more at the story if you feel like hurling up your breakfast.
But really, I digress. My biggest problem with this bullshit is the number of people on this comment board claiming to be good Christians and Americans and whatever. First off–WE ARE ALL IMMIGRANTS! All of our European (re: WHITE) ancestors came to this country at one point too, whether it was for asylum, opportunity, or just plain old adventure. But we all came from someplace.
Secondly, last time I checked, Jesus was about caring for others and love and all that jazz. But no, the way American Christian assholes would have it, Jesus would be wrapped in an American flag, bombing abortion clinics, executing homosexuals, clutching a rifle, sitting on a drum of gasoline and pissing on Mexico, the Middle East, and Faggy France. Sorry folks, but Jesus would not want you to have guns. He would not approve of your “god hates fags” signs. He would tell you to give your money to the less needy. And he would tell you to let those illegal immigrants in.
It really worries me that I, an atheist, understand Christian Doctrine more than some of you neo-con, racist, hatred spewing bigots.
Finally, and I am hi-jacking this from my good friend Nicki, who actually posted the original story on Facebook (thanks Nicki!) , but I am first and foremost a HUMAN and secondly an AMERICAN. And I love other humans and respect for human life more than I love this country, or any country. Some arbitrary lines drawn in the sand and a piece of paper that really means very little to the ass-hats in charge really does little to stir my passions. But people, in this country and all over the world, that are suffering and sick and hungry…that upsets me.
I don’t care if you say I hate America. I love other people. And I hate sharing a country–nay, a planet with people who talk and think like those above.

12 comments
Comments feed for this article
May 13, 2008 at 7:17 pm
Amelia
I am a second generation on my father’s side. I couldn’t even finish reading…sorry…I’ll come back for more later. >_<
May 13, 2008 at 11:29 pm
You know
You have no idea what Jesus was about, no one does. For fuck’s sake Jesus isn’t even his name! The only information or evidence of his existence comes 100 years later. Unfortunately, you cannot say what Yeshu was all about or what he would have and wouldn’t have approved.
May 14, 2008 at 12:21 am
goingtomontreal
Dear You Know-
Ok, so are you saying all of the Christian faith is based on something made up? So we agree. However, Christains worship the Jesus from the BIBLE and the Jesus in the BIBLE explicitly said he was about love and acceptance and compassion.
I rest my case, nutjob.
May 14, 2008 at 12:22 am
StevieG
I don’t know why you deleted my previous comment. All I stated was that you can’t say what Yeshu was about because there is no evidence for his existence. There is no evidence that he existed and no teaching or writings of him materialized until 100 years after his supposed existence.
I’m not going to lie, my wording in the previous comment was somewhat hostile, but not towards you, more towards the whole of Christianity since they don’t even have his name correct.
As you can see, both your logic and theirs are faulty. But what do I know? This comment will probably be deleted as soon as you see it anyway.
May 14, 2008 at 12:24 am
StevieG
My bad on the previous comment, my page didn’t refresh correctly. But come on, nutjob? That’s a bit mean!
May 14, 2008 at 1:38 am
Charles RB
Wow, who knew that illegally crossing a border to work under-the-table was a more heinous and disgusting crime than people-traffickers forcibly abducting & imprisoning 53 people to gain ransom money, a situation inherently meaning there’d be 53 people either killed or sold into sex-slavery if the ransom didn’t turn up?
Very Christian of those posters.
May 14, 2008 at 1:41 am
goingtomontreal
You’re right…nutjob was a tad mean
Forgive me, I find most religious people nutjobs.
I guess what I was trying to point out, maybe not Jesus or Yeshu as a historcal person OR as a Biblical figure isn’t about chugging beer and shooting terrorists.
My apologie for nutjob. It seems as if we are angry at the same people, and the enemy of my enemy is my friend.
May 14, 2008 at 4:12 am
Ryan
Either way you cut this, Christian or not, many of those responses are simply brimming with malice. It is more than that though, some of them are just plain idiotic. Like this one…
“Please, God, I pray to you that my government in some way doesn’t pay for this…no human rights excuses, no nothing. It’ll be interesting to see the circumstances in which these people are let go. It’ll be interesting to see if someone gets piad, and who cuts the check.”
What fucking planet is this guy living on? Yeah, our government is just going to pay the ransom to a group of kidnapping, extortionist criminals; moron.
I found some of these peoples’ buddies here. They seem like a bunch of sane, constructive, and loving Americans!
May 15, 2008 at 1:15 am
Renee
The whole concept of an illegal human being on the planet earth is ridiculous. Borders are a human construction and are being used to enforce exploitation. We should be able to travel freely. All of the anger at so-called illegals is completely misdirected. If we look at global economics, who exactly is responsible for the impoverishment of Mexico, indeed most of the third world? Why should people born in the geographic south live in poverty so that Americans can live in comfort based on unearned privilege? People really need to start taking a humanist approach to issues.
May 15, 2008 at 1:24 am
goingtomontreal
Hi Renee–
Thank you for that. It is ridiculous to me how ANGRY people are about this. In reality, “illegals” come over here to make less money at the shit jobs no one here wants to do. It’s disgusting.
May 16, 2008 at 3:17 am
Renee
I think the thing that I find most ironic is that those that are expressing their righteous indignation have no idea that they are being manipulated. In actually the average worker has far more in common with a so-called illegal alien than they do with the ruling elite. The racist hatred that is encouraged by the bourgeoisie class, is purposeful in that it keeps the proletariat divided. If workers believe that they have nothing in common they will work at cross purposes which in turn benefits the owners of the means of production. Fighting immigration is actually a disservice to the typical American worker. In solidarity so much more could be accomplished.
June 3, 2008 at 6:44 am
Ryan
I read this NYTimes Op-ed today:The Great Immigration Panic and thought of this post. It is pretty sad really.